{
  "project": "skills/ppt-master/references/ai-image-comparison/rendering",
  "generated_at": "2026-05-15",
  "comparison_set": "rendering",
  "baseline": {
    "palette": "cool-corporate",
    "subject": "a confident professional standing beside an upward growth chart, looking forward",
    "composition": "single-subject hero (image-generator.md §4.1 Primitive A)"
  },
  "color_scheme": {
    "primary": "#1E3A5F",
    "secondary": "#F8F9FA",
    "accent": "#D4AF37"
  },
  "deck_style_anchor": "Single subject hero composition, cool-corporate palette: secondary off-white #F8F9FA dominates background (60-70%), primary deep navy #1E3A5F carries main subject, accent gold #D4AF37 in small emphasis points only.",
  "items": [
    {
      "filename": "vector-illustration.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — vector-illustration",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Clean flat vector illustration with bold geometric shapes, sharp edges, no gradients, no shadows, solid flat fills throughout. Subject: a confident professional standing beside an upward growth chart, looking forward. Single dominant subject occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is restrained-corporate: secondary off-white #F8F9FA occupies 60-70% of the canvas as calm breathing space; primary deep navy #1E3A5F carries the main subject in confident solid blocks; accent gold #D4AF37 appears only in one or two small emphasis points totaling under 5% of the area. No fourth color. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding around the subject. No embedded text labels, no HEX codes or color names visible in the image.",
      "alt_text": "Vector illustration hero rendering: confident professional beside growth chart, deep navy on off-white with gold accent",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "flat.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — flat",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Modern flat design with crisp geometric blocks, slightly more decorative than pure vector, clean angular composition, solid flat fills, subtle 8%-opacity drop shadows allowed under layered blocks. Subject: a confident professional standing beside an upward growth chart, looking forward. Single dominant subject occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is restrained-corporate: secondary off-white #F8F9FA occupies 60-70% of the canvas as calm breathing space; primary deep navy #1E3A5F carries the main subject and dominant blocks; accent gold #D4AF37 appears only in one or two small emphasis points totaling under 5% of the area. No fourth color. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding. No embedded text labels, no HEX codes or color names visible.",
      "alt_text": "Flat design hero rendering: professional beside growth chart, geometric blocks in deep navy on off-white with gold accent",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "3d-isometric.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — 3d-isometric",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Isometric 3D rendering with axonometric perspective, subtle ambient shadows at 8% opacity, soft volumetric forms, slight gradient shading on lit faces. Subject: a confident professional standing beside an upward growth chart, looking forward — both subject and chart rendered as isometric 3D forms. Single dominant scene occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is restrained-corporate: secondary off-white #F8F9FA occupies 60-70% of the canvas as calm breathing space; primary deep navy #1E3A5F carries the main isometric forms; accent gold #D4AF37 appears only in one or two small emphasis points totaling under 5% of the area. No fourth color. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding. No embedded text labels, no HEX codes visible.",
      "alt_text": "3D isometric hero rendering: isometric professional and growth chart in deep navy on off-white with gold accent",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "digital-dashboard.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — digital-dashboard",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Polished UI dashboard aesthetic, screen-like surface with cards and chart elements, subtle drop shadows under cards, clean data-viz typography feel, modern SaaS look. Subject: a dashboard view dominated by an upward growth chart card with a confident professional avatar overlaid on the side. Single dominant composition occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is restrained-corporate dashboard: secondary off-white #F8F9FA dominates as the UI surface (about 70%); primary deep navy #1E3A5F carries the main chart bars and dominant card header; accent gold #D4AF37 reserved for one highlighted KPI marker totaling under 5%. Soft 8% drop shadows under cards. No fourth color. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding. No embedded text labels, no HEX codes visible.",
      "alt_text": "Digital dashboard hero rendering: growth chart UI card with professional avatar in deep navy on off-white with gold KPI",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "corporate-photo.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — corporate-photo",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Editorial corporate photography, real human subject in modern office environment, natural soft window lighting, magazine-quality, slight depth of field, photo-realistic. Subject: a confident professional standing beside an upward growth chart projected on a screen or printed on a wall, looking forward. Single dominant subject occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color grading is restrained-corporate: muted off-white #F8F9FA tones in the environment dominate as calm breathing space (about 65%); deep navy #1E3A5F appears as the dominant clothing or screen tone of the subject area; warm gold #D4AF37 grade appears only as a small environmental accent — perhaps a metal detail or warm light glow — under 5% of the area. No saturated extra colors. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding around the subject. No embedded text in the image.",
      "alt_text": "Corporate photography hero rendering: real professional in modern office beside growth chart, navy and off-white grade with gold accent",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "blueprint.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — blueprint",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Technical schematic blueprint style, fine grid background, monospace cues, drafting lines, blueprint annotation aesthetic with measurement marks and structural callout lines. Subject: a stylized blueprint of a confident professional figure standing beside a schematic upward growth chart, both rendered as engineering drawings with clean line weights. Single dominant composition occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is restrained-corporate blueprint: secondary off-white #F8F9FA carries the paper field with subtle grid (about 65%); primary deep navy #1E3A5F carries all schematic linework and the dominant figure outlines (about 28%); accent gold #D4AF37 appears only as one or two highlighted callout markers totaling under 5%. No fourth color. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding. No embedded text or measurement numbers as legible labels.",
      "alt_text": "Blueprint schematic hero rendering: technical drawing of professional and growth chart in deep navy on off-white with gold callouts",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "editorial.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — editorial",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Magazine-style editorial infographic, refined typography hierarchy, balanced gutters, paper-grain texture at 8% opacity, deliberate negative space, considered composition with magazine-spread feel. Subject: a confident professional rendered as an editorial illustration standing beside an upward growth chart styled as a magazine data visualization. Single dominant subject occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is restrained editorial: secondary off-white #F8F9FA carries the magazine-paper field with subtle paper-grain (about 65%); primary deep navy #1E3A5F anchors the dominant figure and main chart block (about 28%); accent gold #D4AF37 appears as one thin horizontal rule and one small highlight marker totaling under 7%. No fourth color. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding. No embedded text or labels visible in the image.",
      "alt_text": "Editorial magazine hero rendering: professional and growth chart with magazine-spread feel, navy on cream-white with gold rule",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "sketch-notes.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — sketch-notes",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Hand-drawn sketch-notes style on warm cream paper background, black ink outlines with slight wobble, pastel color fills with slight hand-painted overshoot beyond edges, organic hand-lettered feel, doodle aesthetic. Subject: a confident professional figure hand-drawn beside an upward growth chart sketched as a doodle with arrows and small annotation marks. Single dominant composition occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is restrained-corporate sketched: cream paper field #F8F9FA dominates (about 65%); primary deep navy #1E3A5F carries the main ink linework and dominant figure (about 28%); accent gold #D4AF37 appears as one highlighted hand-drawn arrow or doodle decoration totaling under 7%. No fourth color. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding. No embedded text or hand-lettered words visible.",
      "alt_text": "Sketch-notes hero rendering: hand-drawn professional and doodle growth chart on cream paper, navy ink with gold accent",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "ink-notes.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — ink-notes",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Pure white background with sparse black ink drawing, hand-drawn linework, deliberate empty space, near-monochrome with one semantic accent color in 1-3 small focal points only. Subject: a confident professional figure hand-drawn in minimal black ink strokes beside an upward growth chart sketched with sparse confident lines. Single dominant composition occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is mono-ink shifted to the deck's HEX: pure white background (about 60%); deep navy #1E3A5F replaces the typical black ink for all linework and the dominant figure (about 33%); accent gold #D4AF37 appears as one small semantic emphasis dot or arrow totaling under 7%. No other colors. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding. No embedded text or words visible.",
      "alt_text": "Ink-notes hero rendering: minimal navy ink drawing of professional and growth chart on white with gold accent dot",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "chalkboard.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — chalkboard",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Chalk drawing on a dark green chalkboard surface, white and pale chalk strokes with slight smudge texture, classroom feel, hand-drawn chalk linework. Subject: a confident professional figure drawn in white chalk beside an upward growth chart sketched in chalk strokes with arrows. Single dominant composition occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior — chalkboard adapted to deck HEX: deep dark chalkboard surface dominates (about 65%); pale off-white chalk #F8F9FA renders all primary linework and the dominant figure (about 28%); warm gold chalk #D4AF37 appears only in one or two small highlights totaling under 7%. No fourth chalk color. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding. No embedded text or written words visible on the chalkboard.",
      "alt_text": "Chalkboard hero rendering: chalk drawing of professional and growth chart on dark green board with white chalk and gold accent",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "watercolor.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — watercolor",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Painterly watercolor style with soft bleeding edges, organic color washes, slight paper grain, hand-painted brush feel, no hard outlines. Subject: a confident professional figure painted in watercolor beside an upward growth chart suggested through soft watercolor washes and brush strokes. Single dominant composition occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is restrained-corporate watercolor: soft off-white #F8F9FA paper field dominates (about 65%); deep navy #1E3A5F watercolor wash carries the main figure and chart with soft bleeding edges (about 28%); warm gold #D4AF37 watercolor highlights appear in one or two small concentrated wash spots totaling under 7%. No fourth pigment. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding. No embedded text or letters visible.",
      "alt_text": "Watercolor hero rendering: painted professional and growth chart with soft navy washes on off-white paper with gold highlights",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "warm-scene.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — warm-scene",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Golden-hour cinematic warmth, soft directional sunlight from low angle, warm color grading throughout, atmospheric haze, lifestyle photography feel. Subject: a confident professional standing beside an upward growth chart bathed in warm golden-hour light, looking forward toward the light source. Single dominant subject occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color grading is restrained-corporate warmed: soft off-white #F8F9FA highlights carry the warmly lit field and atmospheric haze (about 60%); deep navy #1E3A5F appears in the shadowed clothing and shadowed side of the chart (about 30%); warm gold #D4AF37 grade carries the golden-hour light itself and rim lighting on the subject totaling about 10%. No saturated extra colors. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding. No embedded text in the image.",
      "alt_text": "Warm-scene hero rendering: cinematic golden-hour photo of professional and growth chart with navy shadows and gold light",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "screen-print.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — screen-print",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Halftone screen-print poster art, limited flat colors, visible halftone dot pattern in transitional zones, slight color misregistration for silkscreen authenticity, retro poster aesthetic. Subject: a confident professional figure rendered as a stylized poster silhouette beside an upward growth chart simplified to bold poster shapes. Single dominant composition occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is restrained-corporate poster: off-white #F8F9FA carries the poster field (about 60%); deep navy #1E3A5F is the dominant flat poster ink for the figure and chart (about 33%); warm gold #D4AF37 is the second poster ink in one or two emphasis blocks totaling under 7%. Halftone dot transitions between color zones. Slight misregistration. No fourth ink. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding. No embedded text or poster lettering visible.",
      "alt_text": "Screen-print hero rendering: halftone poster of professional and growth chart in navy and gold on off-white with retro silkscreen feel",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "fantasy-animation.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — fantasy-animation",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Hand-drawn animation style reminiscent of Studio Ghibli — soft warm linework, painted watercolor-style backgrounds, gentle character expression, storybook warmth, animated film look. Subject: a confident professional character drawn in animation style standing beside an upward growth chart rendered as part of a warm storybook scene. Single dominant subject occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is restrained-corporate softened for animation: soft off-white #F8F9FA painted background (about 60%); deep navy #1E3A5F appears as the character's clothing and dominant scene tone (about 30%); warm gold #D4AF37 appears as warm light glow and character highlights totaling about 10%. No clashing saturated colors. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding. No embedded text or letters visible.",
      "alt_text": "Fantasy-animation hero rendering: Ghibli-style professional and growth chart with navy clothing and warm gold light on soft off-white",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "pixel-art.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — pixel-art",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "8-bit pixel art aesthetic, blocky pixels with sharp pixel edges and no anti-aliasing, retro game feel, limited color palette per fill, deliberate jagged edges. Subject: a confident professional pixel character standing beside an upward growth chart rendered as a pixelated bar chart. Single dominant composition occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is restrained-corporate pixel: off-white #F8F9FA fills the background pixel field (about 60%); deep navy #1E3A5F is the dominant pixel color for the character and chart bars (about 33%); warm gold #D4AF37 appears as one or two small accent pixel clusters — a highlighted bar tip or pixel sparkle — under 7%. No fourth color. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding. No embedded pixel text or letters visible.",
      "alt_text": "Pixel-art hero rendering: 8-bit professional and bar chart in navy pixels on off-white with gold accent pixels",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "nature.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — nature",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Organic earthy illustration with botanical details, hand-drawn natural forms, leaves and organic textures, slightly desaturated earthy line quality. Subject: a confident professional figure standing in a natural outdoor setting beside an upward growth chart formed organically from stylized plant shapes or rising leaves. Single dominant subject occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is restrained-corporate naturalized: soft off-white #F8F9FA carries the open natural breathing space (about 60%); deep navy #1E3A5F shifted slightly toward natural-darkened tone for the figure and organic forms (about 30%); warm gold #D4AF37 appears as small natural sun-detail pops — sunlit leaf tips, a small flower — totaling about 10%. Earth-toned, slightly desaturated. 12-20% inner safe-zone padding. No embedded text or letters.",
      "alt_text": "Nature hero rendering: professional in natural setting with organic growth chart in navy and earthy gold on off-white",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "minimalist-swiss.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — minimalist-swiss",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Strict Swiss-grid minimalist composition with rigorous modular grid alignment, reduced geometric primitives (clean rectangles, perfect circles, single-weight lines), no decoration, no gradients, no shadows, generous aggressive whitespace. Subject: a stylized confident professional silhouette standing beside an upward growth chart reduced to a single straight diagonal line — both elements snapped to the grid. Single dominant composition occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition), with deliberate negative space carrying as much weight as filled areas. Color behavior is restrained-corporate: secondary off-white #F8F9FA occupies 70% of the canvas as vast calm field; primary deep navy #1E3A5F carries the silhouette and chart line as flat solid block; accent gold #D4AF37 appears only as one thin horizontal rule or single small dot at a rule-of-thirds intersection, under 3%. No fourth color. 18-20% inner padding. No embedded text or labels.",
      "alt_text": "Minimalist-swiss hero rendering: gridded silhouette and chart line in deep navy on vast off-white field with single gold accent",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "glassmorphism.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — glassmorphism",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Modern glassmorphism aesthetic with layered semi-transparent frosted-glass panels, thin 1px highlight strokes on panel top/left edges, large soft drop shadows (20% opacity, generous spread) for real depth, soft gradient background blurring through panels. Subject: a confident professional figure rendered as a clean solid silhouette inside the main frosted-glass panel, standing beside an upward growth chart shown as a polished glass card with crisp data marks. Single dominant composition occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is restrained-corporate glass: secondary off-white #F8F9FA forms the soft gradient field (about 60%); primary deep navy #1E3A5F carries the figure silhouette and chart data inside the glass panel (about 32%); accent gold #D4AF37 appears as one small focal indicator on the chart, under 5%. Polished, premium, futuristic-friendly. 12% inner safe-zone padding. No embedded text or labels.",
      "alt_text": "Glassmorphism hero rendering: frosted-glass panel with professional silhouette and chart in deep navy on soft off-white gradient with gold accent",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "vintage-poster.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — vintage-poster",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Mid-century modern poster aesthetic with bold geometric shapes with rounded organic edges, slightly off-axis retro composition, halftone dot pattern at 12% opacity overlaying fills, subtle paper grain at 10% opacity, slight ink misregistration along edges suggesting screen-print authenticity, thick hand-aware lines. Subject: a stylized retro confident professional silhouette standing beside an upward growth chart shown as angular geometric bars, both in mid-century poster character. Single dominant composition occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is restrained-corporate in mid-century register: secondary off-white #F8F9FA (slightly toned toward warm paper) carries about 60% of the canvas; primary deep navy #1E3A5F forms the silhouette and bars as confident flat blocks with halftone overlay (about 32%); accent gold #D4AF37 appears as one small geometric circle or thin horizontal rule, under 8%. Three colors total. 12% inner padding. No embedded text or letters.",
      "alt_text": "Vintage-poster hero rendering: mid-century retro silhouette and angular bars in deep navy on warm off-white with gold geometric accent",
      "status": "Generated"
    },
    {
      "filename": "paper-cut.webp",
      "purpose": "Rendering comparison — paper-cut",
      "aspect_ratio": "16:9",
      "prompt": "Layered paper-cut craft aesthetic with crisp scissor-cut edges (slightly irregular, hand-aware, not mathematically perfect), soft 8-12% drop shadows under each cut-paper layer giving real tactile depth, paper grain at 12% opacity over each color sheet, no outlines anywhere (shapes defined by paper edges only). Subject: a confident professional figure built as layered paper cutouts standing beside an upward growth chart constructed as stacked paper rectangles of increasing height. Single dominant composition occupying 60-70% of the canvas (hero composition). Color behavior is restrained-corporate as paper: secondary off-white #F8F9FA forms the background paper sheet (about 60%); primary deep navy #1E3A5F is the dominant paper-layer color for the figure and chart bars (about 32%); accent gold #D4AF37 appears as one small cut paper detail — a bar tip highlight or a small paper-cut sun — under 8%. Each layer casts a soft 10% drop shadow. 12% inner padding. No embedded text or letters.",
      "alt_text": "Paper-cut hero rendering: layered paper silhouette and stacked paper bars in deep navy on off-white sheet with gold paper accent",
      "status": "Generated"
    }
  ]
}
